Is Saving Money the Number One Reason for Spending It?

There’s a question I’ve been asking myself lately which is this: Is saving money the number one reason for spending it?

Think about that for a second.

Here’s the question again: Is saving money the number one reason for spending it?

What does that even mean? Let’s walk through a hypothetical scenario to consider this further.


Discount Offer Sign

Spending Money to Save Money

Imagine that you’re in a store like Banana Republic looking for a new pair of pants. As you’re browsing around, you come across a sale rack. It doesn’t have any pants, but you’ll go ahead and take a look anyway.

As you glance at the clothes, you notice a sweater that’s on sale. It also happens to be 50% off. A beautiful new sweater for 50% off! How can you pass up a deal like that?

So you look at it for a second, consider how much you like it, and decide to buy it.

Forget the fact that it’s May and you won’t need a sweater again until November, and forget that it wasn’t on your shopping list. It was on sale! It was 50% off! How could you possibly pass it up!

This is what I call spending money for the sake of saving it—you purchase something that you may or may not have bought otherwise, only because it’s on sale and enables you to “save money.”

Like it or not, this is an everyday occurrence in the consumer economy we live in. We don’t just buy things that we need or buy things that have been on our shopping list for two months—we buy many things that catch our eye at the time, and often, we spend money we wouldn’t spend otherwise, all in the name of saving.

Now if you own a business, this is a phenomena you want to take advantage of.

How to Take Advantage of Your Customers’ Desire to Save Money

When it comes to getting people’s attention, there are only a few things that are guaranteed attention getters—one is making or saving money and another is losing weight. There are a few more items on the list, but these are two of the biggest.

It’s really true. Nearly everyone wants to lose weight, and people can rarely ignore store signs that indicate a sale. 50% off signs in a clothing store capture attention like a red cape waved by a matador.

Smart businesses realize this and know that offering discounts is one of the number one ways to get customers’ attention. So how can you offer discounts without giving away the farm? How do you offer discounts without losing money from marking prices down too much and too frequently?

6 Smart Ways to Offer Discounts

Here are six smart ways to offer discounts in order to take advantage of our customers’ desire to save money:

  1. Infrequent sales: If you offer sales too frequently, customers get used to getting a deal. Instead of paying full price, they wait until they can buy at half off. Most businesses can’t survive by selling everything at a 50% discount, so you don’t want to condition customers to wait for sales. One company that comes to mind for giving too many discounts is a photobook-making website that offers 50%-off discounts every month. Since I know sales come out monthly, I refuse to pay full price for anything. It’s also annoying and makes it confusing to know what the real value of the product is. As an alternative, a lot of clothing stores spread sales out by offering them during holidays. This is a great way to not offer discounts too frequently. Sometimes people can wait for the sales, but other times they need a product now and can’t wait for the next sale date. The lesson to be learned is that you don’t want to provide discounts too frequently and condition customers to only buy when there’s a sale.
  2. Last chance prices: Another way to smartly discount is to offer a product as the last chance to buy at a particular price. Copyblogger does this quite frequently when they offer their products for sale at a current price and let people know that the cost is going up soon. In order to “save money” and “take advantage” of the current low price, customers should buy now. This accomplishes two things: 1) It doesn’t condition customers to expect discounts and 2) It creates a sense of urgency that pushes some customers off of the fence who have been waiting for the right time to buy. This strategy doesn’t work for every business, but when it does, it works well.
  3. Buy one get one free offers: Another smart discounting strategy is to offer products at a buy one get one free price. This helps to get people in the door who are looking to save money. Someone who may not have purchased a shirt otherwise can be drawn into the store for a buy-one-get-one-free sale and then end up purchasing a sweater they may not have purchased without seeing the sale sign. Another option for this is a buy-one-get-one-half-off offer. With a discount like this, businesses don’t lose as much money on the second product, but they do take advantage of an attention-grabbing discount offer.
  4. Discounts on secondary products: Businesses such as hair salons may not want to offer discounts on haircuts every month. This would condition customers to expect discounts on the salon’s most important service. Instead, salons could offer discounts on secondary products like hair gel and shampoo. Customers pay full price to get their haircut, but they get discounts on secondary products that have a high margin. Even though many customers won’t end up purchasing hair products, a discount offer captures attention and gets some customers into the salon.
  5. Off-peak discounts: Another option is an off-peak discount. Hotels do this by charging less for off-peak dates than peak dates. It makes sense because the high demand during peak season means hotels can easily rent out all of the rooms at a higher price, but the lower demand during off-peak season means they’ll have trouble filling all of the rooms. Offering discounted rates in the off-peak season helps to get customers to book rooms during these times. This displaces some of the demand from the peak season. Considering a barber shop as another example, barbers could offer a discounted rate from Monday through Friday from 10 am to 5 pm since most people come in to get their hair cut at nights and on weekends. The off-peak discount would displace some of the traffic, increasing haircuts during off-peak hours when not many people show up and decreasing the wait times during on-peak haircutting hours. This is a win/win for barber shops.
  6. Package deals: McDonalds has been successfully using package deals for quite some time. They offer a combo meal of a drink, fries, and burger at a discounted price. Even though customers only save a little money, most people opt for the combo since it “saves money.” Even though they end up spending more to buy a drink and fries they may not have purchased otherwise, they do it to “save.” It ends up being a great deal for McDonalds because drinks and fries are high-margin items. Package deals are an easy way to get people to spend more total dollars than they would have spent without a package price.

As you can see, there are lots of ways to use discounts to get customer attention and increase demand for products. When carried out smartly, it can be done without conditioning customers to expect a discounted price. It’s also an excellent way to get customer attention and to convince them to spend money they may not spend otherwise.

What about you? What kinds of discounts would you add to this list? Do you know of any other smart ways to offer discounts without devaluing products?

If yes, leave a comment, and let’s talk about it in the comments below.

Comments

  1. You’ve got to stay awake and alert, and be smarter than the sale. I know I’ll use the sweater, since I’m always looking for quality clothes to wear to work, so I win. If I buy something that won’t really be useful simply because it’s a bargain, I lose.

    The smartest method I’m seeing for offering a discount is the prompt to share with friends. Lots of deal sites and online retailers will offer a discount if you share your purchase or a specific link with your followers. It requires a much lower investment than conventional advertising, and everyone wins. Smart, in my book.

    • Joseph Putnam says:

      Hi Wendy, I agree that staying alert is key, but frequently the discount bug sneaks up to bite. :) Buying stuff on sale is a great way to save money, but it’s also a super easy way to buy something you really don’t need.

      I prefer the 30 day test where, if I’ve wanted or needed a product for 30 days or more, then there’s a good chance that it’s actually something worth buying. :)

  2. This is a genius article. The concept of spending money because your’e trying to save it has a touch of Seth Godin in it, somehow. You didn’t get this from him, did you? :)

    • Joseph Putnam says:

      I’m glad you liked the post, and Seth’s comment below proves that it wasn’t stolen from him. :)

  3. He didn’t, Martyn.

    This actually veered in the opposite direction I expected. Some would say that spending money is the reason to save it!

    I think people buy that sweater NOT because it’s a high value item, but because the act of the save creates genuine joy in some people. They bought the joy, not the sweater.

    • Joseph Putnam says:

      Hi Seth,

      I agree that for a lot of people saving money on an item like a sweater creates a moment of “joy,” but I also feel like it leads to a lot of waste.

      In my opinion, greater “joy” can be derived from saving money and spending it wisely on items that are genuinely useful than spending it willy nilly on items that happen to be on sale. I learned over the years that a lot of the things I buy on sale tend to sit in my closet because I didn’t truly need them but I bought them anyway because I wanted to “save money.”

  4. You know, the copyblogger tactic totally worked on me. That’s why I bought premise. And I loved the value I got for my dollar. But I wouldn’t have considered it over something like Unbounce without that discount….or should I say one-time-ever offer.

    The off-season discounting mostly works for non-product-based businesses. Hotel rooms have the cost of their rooms at all times, so not filling them costs the same as filling them (sort of). But a sweater maker has hard cost of inventory, and just needs to move that inventory, so off-season discounts turn into inventory clear-outs, which is another kind of deal that can get a person like me!!!

    • Joseph Putnam says:

      The Copyblogger tactic totally worked on me as well … twice. I was on the fence and saving money was all the incentive I needed.

      Off-season totally works for non-product based businesses, and I think hair salons are a good example where it’s underused (although that would be off-peak and not off-season).

  5. Harrison Li says:

    Good question, I came up with 2 conclusions from the purpose of saving money:
    1. For future consumption.
    2. The pleasure of holding greater amounts of wealth.

Speak Your Mind

*